Putting aside all rivalry & bias and looking at football from a pure footballing basis. How
anyone can say Wenger is not a good coach is beyond me. To have two sides playing
the kind of brand on display must take someone who know what they doing. Obviously
the players have the talent to play in that manner as well, but what I admire most is
the freedom allowed them to put it on display.
Nobody ever says that Wenger is not a good coach. Wenger has a great eye for talent and has a great vision of how football should be played and how players should be developed
BUT
He is not coaching at Ajax, Saprissa or Tahuichi. The name of the game is not to develop excellent 16 – 19 year olds and then send them elsewhere, but to win titles.
Wenger will have the same problem with these youths that he has had over the past couple years, he has no big, established, winners in his side to guide them while he introduces them.
For all the teams they beat in the Carling Cup last year this same side plus the graduates Denilson, Traore, Djourou and company get 5 from Spurs in the semis. There is just no substitute for experience and you could bring in one, two or three good youngsters alongside big players and they will flourish. 5 and 6 and they will only learn by years of getting licks.
Fabregas is a boss. He start playing at 16 alongside Vieira, Pires, Ljungberg, Henry and Campbell. A perfenct education for a footballer and now we see the rewards. Wilshire is 16 too, but put him in the current fickle Arsenal side and he will learn the hard, long way.
So Wenger will have to put them out there and they learn together by getting several years of decent licks (by Arsenal standards this could be year 2 or year 3 of that process) but the fans and press will continue to jam them.
Everybody does talk about the kids that SAF put out in the 90’s but he put 4 or 5 players in a side with proven winners around them Keane, Bruce, Pallister, Cole, Irwin, Giggs, Schmeichel. Wenger either wait too long or didn’t anticpate that the likes of Toure, Senderos, Van Persie and Almunia couldn’t bridge the leadership gap between the last team he had (Vieira, Pires, Ljungberg etc) and these youngsters. Or the players he was grooming at that time, the group with Bentley, Aliadiere and Lupoli, didn’t develop as planned. Either way he has a problem now if the goal is to win a title now.
What Wenger is trying to do is admirable. If it works it will be unique. To have a system where the first team is the best in the world and every year or two years you roll in 2 or 3 homegrown players and roll out 2 or 3 that long in the tooth. Yuh wouldn’t have to worry about transfer fees or players knowing system or wanting to play for the club. Once the club is winning and playing “better football than Brazil” (©Palos) they could dominate for a decade, easy.
But right now it is stop start because they not wining and they not willing ot pay for a solid core to begin with. Flamini and Hleb wnet through they growing pains and buss it. Adebayor looking to do the same thing and even Fabregas making noises about Barca. If them 2 gone he have to start over. The short term stop gap to keep players who not winning is money so Wenger have to make up his mind whether he want to splash some cash for big players or wait a little longer.