Under BSC we had 2 home games and we got 1 point. Under Beenie we had 2 home games and got 6 points. Dat is oversimplifying it, but it is enough for me to say Beenie doing a better job.... significantly better.
But playing Devil's advocate look at the teams we got those 6 points from, Guatemala and Panama. Just glance at the standings and you'll see they are much weaker than Costa Rica and USA that we got the 1 point from under BSC. So Beenie got 6 points from the 2 easiest games out of the 10 we have to play in the entire Hex. And don't forget we were 5 mins away from losing to Guatemala at home and Beenie had the services of Latapy which BSC didn't have. Could BSC have taken those same 6 points? we'll never know
I would say that if you watch the team's performances before and after Beenie, the team has played better football than they did under BSC, but just haven't been able to convert chances into goals.
But then again I think back to those early home games against the USA and Costa Rica and realize that we had a very good chance to at least draw the USA and beat Costa Rica in those games if we had converted some chances (e.g. Tiger vs USA, Nigel Pierre vs Costa Rica)
And just looking at our 2 games against the USA, I realize that we played a much better game against the US under BSC than we did under Beenie (1 shot in 90 mins!) but of course the US is much stronger now than they were in February and we were playing away with 10 men for a half so it's impossible to compare.
I will say this, if Beenie was coaching we would NEVER have lost 5-1 away to Guatemala and that to me is a big difference, BUT we might still have lost 2-1 or something.
So far Beenie has won the 2 games we should have won and lost the 3 games we should have lost, on paper.
SO I think Beenie needs to get us some positive results besides the Panama and Guatemala home games before we can say he really improved our chances of qualifying significantly. Panama away and Mexico home are the big tests for Beenie as those are 2 close games on paper that we could easily get 0 points from or we could get 6.