OUR PLANES ARE SAFE
ATR: Complaints damaging to company's imageBy Curtis Rampersad Business Editor
Story Created: Dec 15, 2010 at 11:49 PM ECT
(Story Updated: Dec 15, 2010 at 11:49 PM ECT )
European manufacturer ATR says its planes are safe and the People's Partnership Government's suggestions there may be safety issues with its aircraft have no basis in fact.
The southern France-based turboprop aircraft maker said yesterday it has noted discussions in Trinidad and Tobago during the past couple weeks about the acquisition by State carrier Caribbean Airlines (CAL) of nine ATR airplanes to renew its fleet.
Approved by Cabinet and agreed to by ATR and Caribbean Airlines in September, the deal for the 68-seat ATR 72-600 aircraft is valued at US$200 million. However, the deal and the firing of former CAL CEO Capt Ian Brunton are now at the heart of an impasse between the George Nicholas-led board and Works and Transport Minister Jack Warner.
Part of the discussions on the deal have elicited concerns about the safety of ATR aircraft and the need to review this in the context of CAL's choice of aircraft. ATR, however, did not take too kindly to the insinuation of such discussion.
"First of all, ATR cannot accept that the safety of its products is called into question when there is absolutely no technical or factual basis for this to be an issue," the company said in a statement yesterday.
"Furthermore, the fact that these safety concerns are raised after the joint media announcement of the agreement between CAL and ATR and the payment of commitment fees makes it even more damaging for the image of ATR and its products."
The company said the claims were damaging to its reputation.
Brunton had negotiated the deal with ATR to boost Caribbean Airlines' fleet before he was fired by the CAL board of directors last month.
CAL paid a deposit of US$1.8 million for the planes, which were planned for use on the airbridge between Trinidad and Tobago. The airline planned to take delivery of the aircraft next year.
Warner said the board showed him "no respect" and did not inform him it had fired Brunton. He suggested Nicholas was more interested in securing planes from another foreign manufacturer, Bombardier, out of Canada.
Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar said, following a post-Cabinet meeting in Tobago last week, "An issue has arisen with respect to safety of the aircraft, the preferred aircraft, from the former board and the present board is raising safety issues."
Government then agreed to hire an international aviation safety expert to evaluate the concerns of the CAL board. Attorney General Anand Ramlogan announced on Tuesday London, England-based aviation expert John Dunne had been hired to evaluate the safety concerns raised by the CAL directors.
ATR, in a statement from spokesman David Vargas, responded yesterday: "As a well-recognised international aircraft manufacturer, ATR has always placed safety at the forefront of its everyday work and efforts. The following factual elements of information show that its aircraft are safe and trusted worldwide:
• Over 850 ATR aircraft are being operated every day by 150 commercial airlines in 90 countries around the world, accumulating some 21 million flights per day in the world, with an aircraft landing at any 20 seconds without any restriction or concern regarding safety.
• The ATR aircraft are certified by the international civil aviation authorities in all of these countries, including the European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) and the US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA). The ATR products fully comply with the very stringent certification requirements of the CS25 and FAR 25 Rules, which are the same applied to narrow-body and wide-body aircraft made by Boeing and Airbus.
• In addition to CAL, many other major airlines and leasing companies around the world have selected ATR (two most recently were Azul in Brazil and Steven Udvar-Hazy's Air Lease in the US). ATR currently has more than half of the market share in sales and deliveries.
"Declarations inferring that ATR aircraft are unsafe not only harm ATR's image as a company but, also, the image of all of the professionals in the aeronautical industry that are connected with the operation of ATR aircraft. There is no doubt that any qualified aviation professional would rely on work performed by airworthiness authorities.
ATR said the agreement with CAL resulted from an exhaustive and thorough technical and economic analysis by airline management and a "detailed comparison with the competition".
"This long selection process led to the designation of our product and commercial offer as the best solution for the airline," the company said, adding: "Given all these elements, and in light of the fact that safety of ATR aircraft is not a credible issue, ATR has serious concerns as to the real reasons why this decision and the signed agreement between Caribbean Airlines and ATR are being called into question. To date, ATR has not been contacted directly by the airline or the Government to be informed directly of the situation."
Accidents involving ATR and Bombardier aircraft
ATR
• October 31,1994—American Eagle (Simmons Airlines) ATR 72; Flight 4184; near Roselawn, Indiana, USA: This was a scheduled domestic flight from Indianapolis and Chicago. During descent, the crew activated the airframe de-icing system. The crew was in a holding pattern at about 10,000 feet (3050m) and while the aircraft was descending to 8,000 feet, the aircraft went out of control due to the effects of icing, and crashed. The four crew members and 64 passengers were all killed. The icing occurred in areas of the wings that were beyond the area protected by the de-icing system.
• November 11, 1999—Air Botswana ATR 42; Gaborone, Botswana: An Air Botswana pilot, who had been grounded for medical reasons, took off alone in an Air Botswana ATR42 airliner and crashed it into two of the airline's other ATR42s on the ground. Fortunately, there was no one else in the other two aircraft. The pilot was the only person killed in this event.
• August 2005—Tuninter ATR 72; near Palermo, Italy: The aircraft was on an unscheduled international flight from Bari, Italy, to Djerba, Tunisia, when the aircraft reportedly developed engine trouble. The crew ditched the aircraft off the coast of Palermo. The aircraft had been on a scheduled domestic flight from Kish Island in the Persian Gulf. Two of the four crew members and 14 of the 35 passengers were killed.
• November 4, 2010—AeroCaribbean; CU-T1549; ATR 72-212; Flight 883; near Guasimal, Sancti Spiritus Province, Cuba: The aircraft was on a domestic flight from Santiago to Havana, Cuba. The crew reported an emergency situation shortly before the aircraft crashed in mountainous terrain. All seven crew members and 61 passengers were killed.
Bombardier
• December 16 1997—Air Canada CRJ-100ER; Fredericton, Canada: The aircraft was on a scheduled domestic flight from Toronto to Fredericton. The aircraft was destroyed, but none of the three crew or 39 passengers were killed.
• November 21, 2004—China Yunnan Airlines (China Eastern) CRJ-200; Baotou, China: The aircraft crashed shortly after taking off on a scheduled domestic flight from Baotou to Shanghai. The six crew members and 47 passengers were all killed in the crash.
• August 27, 2006—Delta Connection (Comair) CRJ-100; Lexington, Kentucky, USA: The aircraft was on a scheduled domestic flight from Lexington to Atlanta. The aircraft crashed shortly after takeoff, about a half mile from the end of the departure runway. Two of the three crew members and all 47 passengers were killed.
• November 12, 2009—RwandAir CRJ-100ER; Flight 205; Kigali, Rwanda: A RwandAir CRJ-100ER was on a scheduled flight from Kigali, Rwanda to Kampala, Uganda, and ran into a terminal at the Kigali airport. The nose gear collapsed and the forward portion of the aircraft penetrated the building up to about the position of the forward passenger doors. One of the three crew members and one of the ten passengers were killed.
• Source:
www.airsafe.comhttp://www.trinidadexpress.com/news/OUR_PLANES_ARE_SAFE-111973344.html