NURSE: ROBBIE SLAPPED ME
By AZARD ALI Friday, July 30 2010
Nurse Jocelyn Bowen has sued former President Arthur NR Robinson for assault and slander, accusing him of slapping her at President’s House on November 2, 2000.
Robinson, in his defence, claims Bowen did not tell the truth about what happened on that day.
Bowen and Robinson testified before Justice Ronnie Boodoosingh in the San Fernando High Court yesterday.
Bowen filed the lawsuit on October 28, 2004, in which she sought exemplary and aggravated damages against Robinson for slander and trespass to her person (assault).
The nurse told Justice Boodoosingh that on November 2, 2000, Robinson slapped her on the shoulders at President’s House after he complained she failed to give him his antibiotics.
Led by her attorney Haresh Ramnath, Bowen said she is a registered nurse and was assigned to care for Robinson’s wife, Patricia, at President’s House, St Ann’s. She took up duties on December 24, 1999.
Bowen, of Diamond Vale, Diego Martin, testified her responsibilities were to administer medication for diabetes to Patricia. She also assisted in dressing Patricia. (Patricia died on September 10, 2009 from Alzheimer’s disease.)
Bowen told the judge that at about 7.15 am, on November 2, 2000, Robinson called her and complained that he was not given his antibiotic tablets.
The nurse said the former President then slapped her on the left shoulder. She testified Robinson pushed her with his finger and shouted, “Murderer! Murderer! Get out of my house. I will put you out of my house, ah go cuss yuh! ah go cuss yuh!”
Bowen also gave the court a description of a corridor at President’s House, and said there were nine persons in the corridor where the incident happened.
Senior Counsel Stanley Marcus, instructed by Guy Hannays, represented Robinson and cross- examined Bowen. Marcus suggested to her that the former President had gently touched her on the shoulders in an attempt to ward her off. However, Bowen maintained, “No Sir, I was slapped on my shoulder.”
Robinson, 83, was taken in a wheelchair into the Civil Chamber courtroom via the High Court basement, accompanied by his daughter Margaret and a plainclothes police officer. He was then asked to testify. Robinson was then seated on a chair next to the witness box. He told Boodoosingh, under questioning by Ramnath, that an incident about his medication did take place, but not in the corridor. “It was in the bedroom,” Robinson said, “in which I did not receive my antibiotics.”
Asked by Ramnath if he slapped Bowen, Robinson said his former nurse was not telling the truth. “She was approaching me and I touched her gently on the shoulders,” Robinson said.
Ramnath then suggested to the former President that he was not telling the truth.
“In your witness statement you admitted that an incident happened on the corridor, but you are now saying that it happened in the bedroom. I am suggesting that you are not telling the truth, Mr Robinson,” Ramnath said.
Robinson replied, “As I said, I gently poked her on the shoulders.”
Before Robinson testified, Lenore Dorset was called as a witness and said she was the former executive assistant to Robinson at President’s House. She said an incident happened on November 2, 2000, but it was not until December 6, 2000 that Bowen complained to her about it.
The trial ended with Boodoosingh ordering that Marcus provide written submissions by August 23 and Ramnath is to file his reply by September 14. Boodoosingh said he would deliver his ruling on October 27.