Hopefully most of us will try to keep the posts about the second test match in one thread. It makes no sense trying to follow the same topic in 5 or 6 different threads.
For this test I'd drop Smith, Ganga, Pagon, Deonarine and Browne and bring in Gayle, Sarwan, Lara, Mohammed and either Baugh or Ramdin. I don't think we can bowl out South Africa twice with 3 quick bowlers and 3 part time spinners. We need either a quality all-rounder or a forth bowler and I'd pick the forth bowler to be a spinner. Especially when 71 of the 160 second innings overs was bowled by the part time spinners.
We should not pick players based on talent, we need to pick the best team available. Smith, Pagon and Deonarine are talented, but talent and $1 will buy a bag of Olé.
