PM pushed for Reshmi
Originally printed at
http://www.trinidadexpress.com/news/PM_pushed__for__Reshmi-116547803.htmlBy Camini Marajh Head Investigative Desk
February 19, 2011
Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar, who has rejected public requests to come clean on the appointment process used to catapult Reshmi Ramnarine, a low-level intercept technician, to the top post in the country's premier intelligence-gathering agency, was herself at the heart of the disastrous selection process, Sunday Express investigations have found.
For reasons still unknown, Prime Minister Persad-Bissessar, in a series of moves at the level of both the National Security Council (NSC), of which she is chair, and the Cabinet, pushed through the selection process of an unsuitable candidate she would later defend, who not only did not apply for the top chief spy job, but, also, was never interviewed.
The Sunday Express understands it was the Prime Minister who made the recommendation to the NSC on January 11 for Ramnarine's appointment to the director's chair of the Strategic Services Agency (SSA).
This after the woman who promoted her candidacy for the job, deputy director, SSA, Julie Browne, herself declined the position for "family reasons" after being interviewed by an interministerial committee of the NSC, comprising Attorney General Anand Ramlogan, National Security Minister John Sandy, Legal Affairs Minister Prakash Ramadhar, Justice Minister Herbert Volney and Minister in the Ministry of National Security Subhas Panday.
Last week, it was business as usual for deputy director Browne, who is still to answer why she made the recommendation for her very junior subordinate; why she breached security protocols and did not conduct the requisite background checks for her choice of candidate; why she went outside of her remit to make recommendation in the first place; why she made the recommendation to the Prime Minister and not to her line minister, Sandy, who asked her to put in the Ramnarine nomination; and most troubling of all, why she misled the Prime Minister and the Cabinet about Ramnarine's qualifications and work experience.
Browne, who has proven herself inept in the ensuing Ramnarine spy scandal, has not been censured for the litany of security failings, including her failure to check the references listed in the Ramnarine-submitted resume, in which she herself is named as a character reference.
From all accounts, the deputy SSA director of 14 years would have the country believe she failed to catch on that the resume contained false credentials and she simply assumed the truth of what Reshmi Ramnarine told her about obtaining a degree in information technology from the University of the West Indies (UWI).
Repeated calls to Browne, who is said to be known to the Persad-Bissessar Government, have gone unreturned. The deputy SSA director has also failed to respond to questions about her personal relationship with Ms Ramnarine or reports her choice of candidate for the top spy post was the declared whistle-blower to the Patrick Manning-sanctioned illegal wiretapping of civilians.
Ramnarine, a close friend of the Prime Minister's public engagement and policy adviser, Sasha Mohammed, was introduced to several people at a farewell bash for Mohammed at Trotters Restaurant as "the whistle-blower" in the SIA (Security Intelligence Agency) spy scandal which dominated the local media for several weeks.
In a dramatic Parliament production on November 12 last year, Prime Minister Persad-Bissessar lifted the lid on the sordid world of secretly conducted State spying, which violated the law and constitutional rights of citizens of this country. Then SSA spy chief Nigel Clement, who Persad-Bissessar identified as former prime minister Manning's main man of business, was fired in the ensuing furore over the clandestine activities of the State's spy apparatus.
Browne and another deputy director of the SSA, Trevor Keron Ganpat, were interviewed by the interministerial committee for the top spy post, according to sources with knowledge of the situation. Ganpat, a relative newcomer to the agency and an unknown to the Persad-Bissessar administration, was not viewed as a deserving candidate on the grounds that he was not familiar enough with the inner workings of the agency.
On January 10, Browne secretly submitted the Ramnarine nomination to the Prime Minister. The following day, January 11, Prime Minister Persad-Bissessar pushed through the Browne recommendation for an interim replacement to the spy director's chair at the NSC meeting, according to sources familiar with the matter. Two days later, on January 13, the Prime Minister pushed through ad hoc Cabinet Note 92, which made the case for Ramnarine's appointment for the top job.
The Prime Minister has not responded to requests from this newspaper for a comment on her role in the appointment process of Ms Ramnarine and is reported to have read her Cabinet the riot act at the February 10 meeting about leaks to the media and maintaining strict confidentiality about Cabinet's deliberations.
Last week, the Prime Minister's lieutenants in the Government seemed to have gotten the message, with several ministers repeating their leader's mantra that Ramnarine has resigned and it was now time to move on. They held that the Prime Minister had taken responsibility for the "misstep" made in the initial appointment, and it was now time to put "the story to rest".
No one, however, was willing to talk about the secret Government appointment process which placed the 31-year-old Ramnarine in the top spy job or the personal role the Prime Minister played in the appointment. "You are beating a dead horse. That is yesterday's news," was how one Government minister responded to questions about the process.
Government ministers were eager to talk, instead, about the new candidate, Colonel Albert Griffith, who has an impressive list of military accomplishments and academic credentials. On Friday, the Prime Minister, in formally presenting the Griffith candidacy for the top job, said a letter of invitation offering him the SSA appointment will be issued by the Ministry of National Security. Why this was not done in the Ramnarine case remains a mystery.
From all accounts, the Persad-Bissessar Government seems intent on selling what was a deliberate act as a "misstep" and/or an error and reluctant to provide details or even discuss the appointment process of Ramnarine, which appears to lead right back to the Prime Minister herself.